home : news : reviews : features : fiction : podcast : blogs : t-shirts : wtf?

Pocahontas: 10th Anniversary Edition DVD
Reviewed by Martin Thomas, © 2005

Format: Movie
By:   Mike Gabriel and Eric Goldberg
Genre:   Animation
Released:   May 3, 2005 (DVD release)
Review Date:   May 03, 2005
Audience Rating:   Rated G
RevSF Rating:   6/10 (What Is This?)

After a 10-year slump, Disney's animation department made a powerful comeback in 1989 with The Little Mermaid, a fairy tale by Hans Christian Anderson they turned into an animated musical and filled with humor, identifiable characters, good pacing and several catchy songs. Most notable, besides its modern sensibilities, was the return to classic Disney quality in the entire production. Prior to this we had to convince ourselves that The Brave Little Toaster was something "amazing", but with The Little Mermaid Disney invested a lot of time and money and were well rewarded for their investment.

They followed up strong with Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast and The Lion King — each time changing the art style and raising the standard. They could do no wrong. . . .

But then, in 1995 they released Pocahontas, the "historical" re-telling of the romance between English settler John Smith and the Indian chief Powhatan's daughter, Pocahontas.

It's ten years later and by now most of you had probably seen this movie. Not me. I did kind of a soft boycott of the film when it came out back in 1995, just because of what I knew would be glaring historical inaccuracies. Especially concerning Pocahontas's early and unhappy demise. But now it's 10 years later and . . . eh, I don't mind so much. I mean, if you want a list of goofs you can check them out here.

Personally, I think they're too trifling to get hung up on. I'm willing to grant plenty of poetic license.

Well, except for the way they changed Pocahontas from 12 years old when she meets John Smith to 20-something — which is about how old she was when she died — just to have a Romeo & Juliet-style romance, free of all overtones of statutory rape.

Still, the movie is remarkable in that it is one of the few Disney animated movies to NOT have a happy ending and is the first (also the ONLY) one to be based on real people.

And that's really all there is about it that's remarkable.

I was taken aback by just how flat the movie is. The story relies on all the overused Disney conventions — Broadway-ish songs, comic relief animal pals, defiant female motherless heroines (Cinderella, Ariel, Belle, Princess Jasmine, Jane Porter, etc.) — yet has so much less depth than its predecessors.

The design scheme is minimalist, which works well for the most part, and the background paintings are gorgeous. But the character designs with but a few exceptions are fairly homogenous, their expressions so "subtle" that they barely emote.

Even the hero, John Smith, being such a rugged, well-known adventurer (read: proficient murderer of indigenous people) is little more than a cookie cutter version of Prince Eric from The Little Mermaid. Despite all the research done to make all the costuming and props accurate, John Smith looks like he just got a Queer Eye makeover, with frosted, moussed and tousled hair, circa 1992 A.D. (Think Daryl Hall at the decline of Hall & Oates' popularity.)

Nearly half the movie is taken up by an over abundance of characters bursting into song, which I found myself fast-forwarding through most of the time. With the exception of Colors of the Wind — thanks mostly to Vanessa Williams’s rendition — the songs composed by Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz are pretty forgettable. It's easy to see how Trey Parker and Mark Shaiman might have been inspired to write the soundtrack for South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut.

Most disappointing was to see that the great romance between Pocahontas and John Smith . . . boils down to little more than an afternoon of frolicking in the woods.

But, hey, I'm a grizzled 40-year old man who's been married for 11 years. My days of having my spirit soar with love are long over. I can tell you that my seven-year old daughter was greatly affected by Pocahontas. She cried her eyes out at the end and told me she never wanted to watch it again.

Which means it'll be THE least-watched DVD in our entire collection.


The first disc offers you the chance to watch the original theatrical release or the new edit, which is basically the old edit with one of the songs added back in. The audio commentary offers no behind-the-scenes "dirt" or colorful anecdotes. It's interesting only if you've never watched a DVD with the audio commentary on before. Then there are the usual lame DVD games suitable only for kids too young to work a PlayStation.

The second disc leads off with a 28-minute "Making Of" feature narrated by voice actress Irene Bedard, which looks like it was shot back in 1995. There's also a huge segment on the music of the film where Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz nearly break their arms patting each other on the back.

My favorite segments were those focused on the characters, the design and the storyboards. Especially seeing the alternate version of Pocahontas they passed on. Through out all of these, it's repeatedly mentioned that Irene Bedard didn't just provide the voice of Pocahontas, but was the model for the character, as well . . . and yet I just couldn't see it. Pocahontas looks so much like a young Barbara Carrera to me, while Irene Bedard resembles Jennifer Garner more than her animated counterpart.

Most interesting on disc two is the section with deleted scenes. Most of them are little more than pencil tests, and are just slightly altered scenes that were in the movie anyway, or just more (!!) musical numbers that were cut.


• A scene with a turkey character who was cut from the final line up, which shows that originally the animal characters were going to have voices

• A quick scene in the ship showcasing just how much contempt the crew already had for Governor Ratliffe, which would've made their eventual mutiny more plausible.

• A scene where John Smith explains to Pocahontas the difference between her and English women: basically, that they overdress. It's pretty clear that much of the reason he falls for her is because she's half naked all the time.

It's hard to excited about the extra DVD features of a movie you found lackluster in the first place. Though, even if I were crazy about Pocahontas, I think I'd be disappointed by how unexceptional most of the extras are, especially for a two-disc DVD.

The Movie Itself: 6 out of 10
The DVD Features: 5 out of 10

RevSF contributor Martin Thomas paints with all the colors of his wind. Which turns out to be browns mostly, except when he eats a big bowl of spinach.

Recommend Us
  • Send to a Friend
  • Digg This
  • Reddit It
  • Add to del.ic.ious
  • Share at Facebook
  • Discuss!
  • Send Feedback
  • Slaughter the World
  • LOTR - You Tube Parodies
  • Anime Titles Combined With Movie Titles
  • Movie Forum
  • Related Pages
  • Print This Page
  • Zootopia
  • RevolutionSF Watercooler : Disney Buys Lucasfilm, Internet Cracks In Half
  • RevolutionSF Watercooler: Disney Buys Lucasfilm
  • Search RevSF
  • New on RevSF
  • Star Wars: The Last Jedi
  • Book Probe: BattleMaster, Wade of Aquitaine, Kriendria of Amorium
  • RevSF Podcast: Drowning in Moonlight: Remembering Carrie Fisher
  • Logan
  • RevSF Home


    Things From Our Brains
    Get even more out of RevSF.

    James Bond:
    The History of the Illustrated 007
    RevolutionSF RSS Feed
    Search RevSF

    Random RevSF
    Why Should I Cut Your Throat When I Can Just Ask You For the Money?

    contact : advertising : submissions : legal : privacy
    RevolutionSF is ™ and © Revolution Web Development, Inc., except as noted.
    Intended for readers age 18 and above.